Free Site Registration


Progress... Sort Of

Print
Email
Reprints
July 18, 2011

 

There used to be this great TV spot for a large commercial bank that spoofed its competitors' overlong waiting periods before depositors could get approved for a loan.

It showed an ancient loan officer, his desk and nameplate draped in cobwebs, dismissively tenting his fingers and slowly repeating, "It'll be any day now."

Advertisement

While the cobwebs surrounding the debate over private company reporting standards are perhaps more figurative than real, many in the profession who prepare financial reports have no doubt felt like those impatient customers while awaiting a yea or nay decision to proceed with this 30-plus year issue.

Last week, the Financial Accounting Standards Board announced that it has begun developing a "differential framework" that would help provide a short-term solution for creating distinct standards or exceptions for private companies.

This stopgap measure will apparently have to do until FASB's overseer, the Financial Accounting Foundation, mulls the recommendations of the Blue Ribbon Panel, which suggested that FAF establish a separate board to handle differential standards reporting.

In the interim the Blue Ribbon Panel  suggested that FASB develop a different framework for private company standards.

As such, FASB released a document titled "FASB in Focus" in which it discusses a roadway to the long-sought-after differential standard-setting framework.

FASB identified a half-dozen criteria separating financial reporting considerations of private companies from public issuers: types of users, access to management, investment strategies, ownership structures, accounting resources, and education.

While even a small measure of progress in this discussion - which has been going on for so long it can almost be carbon-dated - it also "buries the lead' as we ink-stained wretches like to say, by skimming over the fact that the last thing FASB wants to do is cede control over private company standard setting, which would likely happen with the creation of a new board.

That, coupled with the uncertainty of the future role of FASB should the SEC eventually decide to forge ahead with International Financial Reporting Standards, has the standard-setter more than a little concerned.

It is not likely to receive any type of private standards endorsement from organizations like the AICPA.

In June, AICPA chief Barry Melancon told more than 1,000 attendees at the institute's Practitioner's Symposium/Tech + Conference that the "status quo" was not acceptable (read: FASB remaining in charge) and called for the creation of the separate board.

Ditto for McGladrey managing office partner and former PCPS chairman Richard Caturano who recently told Accounting Today, "We've been waiting a long time for clarification of some of the standards for private companies. For decades, FASB has been focused on the needs of the public companies."

With roughly 50 percent of the economy comprising  private companies, clearly the time has come to get past the "any day now" mantra.

Short-term solutions are good up to a point, but then eventually you have to clear the cobwebs for good.

 

 

1 Comment

Watch what you ask for, because you might get it. Private company standards might require different and more disclosures than current GAAP does. Information such as who actually owns the company, management's discussion and analysis of the financial position and results of operations, shareholder agreements, other details that are not ordinarily included in financials could wind up being required disclosures.

Posted by: BillMcGovern | July 18, 2011 2:58 PM

Report this Comment

Add Your Comments...

Already Registered?

If you have already registered to Accounting Today, please use the form below to login. When completed you will immeditely be directed to post a comment.

 

Advertisement
Advertisement

What's New at Grant Thornton

May 14, 2012

CEO Stephen Chipman talks about his firm's new brand focus on growth, and its recent M&A activity.

Advertisement

SLIDE SHOW

Top 10 Payroll Mistakes Companies Make

May 14, 2012

Keeping your clients from running afoul of IRS rules around payroll taxes will help them avoid stiff penalties.

10 Years of the Top 100 Firms

May 6, 2012

Tracking trends at the biggest firms in the U.S.

Best Accounting Firm Taglines

April 27, 2012

Our favorite slogans from around the profession.

Favorite Busy Season Activities

April 10, 2012

LinkedIn Accounting members share the best methods to bust stress and boost morale.

The Best Places to Be an Accountant 2012

March 27, 2012

From our 2012 Regional Leaders list, we rank the best parts of the country to operate an accounting firm.

More Wacky Tax Deductions

March 26, 2012

LinkedIn members point out some weird tax deductions their clients have suggested.

7 Tax-Free Benefits for Employees

April 15, 2012

Employee rewards Uncle Sam can't touch.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement