Free Site Registration


Kroeker: Keep Converging With or Without Roadmap

Print
Email
Reprints
New York (October 30, 2009)

By Michael Cohn

SEC Chief Accountant Jim Kroeker said the Financial Accounting Standards Board and the International Accounting Standards Board should proceed with their efforts to converge U.S. and international accounting standards, even though the SEC commissioners have not yet formally approved the proposed roadmap to International Financial Reporting Standards.

Speaking on Friday at a conference on IFRS jointly sponsored by the American Institute of CPAs and the International Accounting Standards Committee Foundation, Kroeker urged standard-setters to look past the dispute over fair value vs. historical cost, and concentrate on providing transparency to investors in areas such as loans and credit losses.

“I think it’s time for the accounting debate to turn away from whether it’s fair value or whether it’s historical cost, but to acknowledge that in some cases both sets of information are important, and then to discuss how best to portray them,” he said.

Kroeker reiterated earlier statements that he and SEC Chair Mary Schapiro had made, indicating the SEC was turning its attention this fall to the proposed IFRS roadmap. When asked about the date, Kroeker said, “There will be follow-up on the roadmap this fall.” Asked to define the word “fall,” he noted that the season ends on Dec. 21.

But Kroeker emphasized that the accounting standard-setting boards should not wait for the SEC to make its decision on the final roadmap, and how the roadmap might change in light of the comments the SEC has received.

“If the boards share the same objective to improve financial reporting, the boards have agreed that the projects that they’re working on are areas that need improvement, not just under U.S. GAAP but under IFRS, then I think convergence efforts should continue or would continue without an SEC finalization of the roadmap,” he said. “That isn’t to say that it isn’t important for us then to also determine the role of international reporting standards in the U.S., and I understand how that can help convergence efforts, but I don’t think the absence of a decision should somehow impede efforts.”

FASB Chairman Robert Herz and IASB Chairman Sir David Tweedie said at the same conference on Thursday that they are aiming to converge U.S. GAAP with IFRS by June 2011, the date recommended by world leaders at last month’s G-20 summit in Pittsburgh (see IASB and FASB to Meet Monthly on Standards Overhaul). The two boards plan to meet on a monthly basis, in person and by video conference, to resolve outstanding issues such as asset impairment and hedge accounting.

The two board chairmen plan to update their memorandum of understanding on their convergence efforts. Kroeker said his top priorities for the new MOU would be resolving the standards for financial instruments, revenue recognition, consolidation and derecognition, in that order.

Kroeker acknowledged that FASB had many issues to resolve, and he did not want to over-burden the board. He said that one of the lessons he had learned from the financial crisis was to be more cognizant of when to ask FASB to divert resources from its convergence efforts. Questions over standards might instead be resolved through other bodies such as the Emerging Issues Task Force, he noted, or companies might instead resolve them through disclosure, as in the Management Discussion and Analysis section of their financial reports.

IASB member James Leisenring discussed the thorny issue of revenue recognition that both boards are working to address. “If you are familiar with the EITF agenda, you know that revenue recognition questions are ongoing,” he said. “They don’t just go away.”

U.S. GAAP and EITF guidance are followed around the world, he noted, because other countries need answers about how to deal with some of the unusual problems that emerge with revenue recognition. “We are trying to converge, we are trying to simplify, and it would be nice if we could develop with clarity some principles for revenue recognition across various industries.”

0 Comments

Be the first to comment on this post using the section below.

Add Your Comments...

Already Registered?

If you have already registered to Accounting Today, please use the form below to login. When completed you will immeditely be directed to post a comment.

 

Follow Accounting Today
Advertisement
Advertisement

Women in Accounting: Where are the Leading Ladies?

May 17, 2013

Marcum’s Nanette Lee Miller and Janis Cowhey McDonagh sat down with managing editor Tamika Cody to discuss some of the obstacles women in the accounting profession face when trying to make their way into leadership positions.

IMA’s Jeff Thomson on the Role and Skills of Management Accountants

May 8, 2013

Institute of Management Accountants president and CEO Jeffrey Thomson discusses why accounting students should consider management accounting as a career, and the IMA's partnership with John Wiley & Sons.

Breaking out of Molds to Get Ahead

May 6, 2013

ConvergenceCoaching partner Jennifer Wilson talks with Accounting Today senior editor Danielle Lee about how female accountants can position themselves better for a promotion at their firms.

Advertisement

SLIDE SHOW

Top 10 Tech Initiatives -- 2013

May 5, 2013

The AICPA's annual list of IT priorities for accounting firms.

Tax Stats: May 2013

April 30, 2013

Our monthly collection of statistics from the world of tax.

10 Biggest Estate Planning Mistakes

April 29, 2013

Help your clients avoid these common pitfalls.

Common E-mail Security Mistakes

April 23, 2013

These five bad habits can make your confidential information -- and that of your clients -- easy to steal.

The Art of the Tax Cartoon

April 9, 2013

A selection of tax cartoons from Philly tax firm Drucker & Scaccetti's 'Finding Humor in Taxes' exhibit.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement