Free Site Registration


Senator Graham Says Reid is ‘Making Things Up’ about Romney's Taxes

Print
Email
Reprints
Washington, D.C. (August 6, 2012)

By Phil Mattingly and Greg Stohr

Bloomberg

Republicans, including Senator Lindsey Graham, accused Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid of lying by saying Mitt Romney hasn’t paid taxes for 10 years.

Graham said Reid was “making things up,” and Republican National Committee Chairman Reince Priebus called Reid a “dirty liar” for leveling the accusations against Romney, the presumptive Republican presidential nominee.

“I just cannot believe that the majority leader of the United States would take the floor twice, make accusations that are absolutely unfounded in my view and, quite frankly, making things up to divert the campaign away from the real issues,” Graham, a South Carolina Republican, said yesterday on CNN’s “State of the Union.”

Republicans and Democrats spent much of the Sunday talk shows sparring over Reid’s claims about Romney’s taxes—accusations the former Massachusetts governor has denied. Democratic President Barack Obama’s advisers and supporters have pressed Romney to release his tax returns in the wake of Reid’s claims. Romney, who has released one year of personal income tax returns and has promised a second, has challenged Reid to “put up or shut up” and reveal his source for the claim.

Reid, a Nevada Democrat, made the allegations in a Senate floor speech last week. His office repeated the claim in an e mailed statement yesterday.

Credible Source
The email, from Reid spokesman Adam Jentleson, said the information comes from “an extremely credible source” and called it “sad” that Republicans were being forced to defend Romney’s decision not to release more tax returns.

Romney has released one year of personal income tax returns, from 2010, showing that he paid an effective tax rate of 13.9 percent on investment income that year. He has promised to release his 2011 returns when accountants are finished with them, and has rejected calls by Democrats and some within his own party to disclose more of his tax returns.

Priebus said on ABC’s “This Week” he wouldn’t respond to a “dirty liar who hasn’t filed a single page of tax returns himself.”

David Axelrod, an Obama campaign strategist, said on “Fox News Sunday” that he didn’t “know who Harry was talking to.” Romney “can resolve this in 10 seconds,” Axelrod said. “Why don’t they just put this to rest? What is it he’s hiding?”

Reckless and Slanderous
Virginia Governor Bob McDonnell, a Republican, said on CBS’s “Face the Nation” that Reid had made a “reckless and slanderous charge.”

“People don’t care about Mitt Romney’s tax returns,” McDonnell said. “They care about their own tax returns.”

Former Pennsylvania Governor Ed Rendell, a Democrat, said on “Face the Nation” that, while voters want to know whether presidential candidates “pay their taxes fairly like everybody else,” Romney’s tax returns are “not a central issue” in a campaign that has focused on the economy.

Romney, in an interview broadcast on CNN’s “State of the Union,” attacked the Obama’s administration’s economic record and said that it is time “for something dramatic and it is not the time to grow government.”

“It’s the time to create the incentives and the opportunities for entrepreneurs and businesses big and small to hire more people and that’s going to happen,” Romney said. “You’re going to see that happen in this country but not under this president.”

Federal Reserve
Romney said the Federal Reserve should refrain from a third round of large-scale asset purchases aimed at boosting the economy. While the first round of bond buying by the U.S. central bank may have had a positive effect, a new round of quantitative easing won’t help the economy, Romney said.

“I am sure the Fed is watching and will try to encourage the economy,” Romney said in the CNN interview. “But I don’t think a massive new QE3 will help the economy.”

The Fed last week moved a step closer to pumping more stimulus into an economy plagued by weakening growth and a jobless rate that has stayed at 8 percent or higher for more than three years. The Federal Open Market Committee on Aug. 1 said it will “closely monitor” economic data and financial developments, suggesting it is focused on the economy’s near- term performance.

The Fed has fought the financial crisis with two rounds of quantitative easing. In the first round starting in 2008, the Fed bought $1.25 trillion of mortgage-backed securities, $175 billion of federal agency debt and $300 billion of Treasuries. In the second round, announced in November 2010, the Fed bought $600 billion of Treasuries.

Economic Doldrums
The economy remains in the doldrums. The government said Aug. 3 that employers added 163,000 jobs in July, more than forecast. The jobless rate, based on a separate survey of households, increased by about four hundredths of a percentage point to 8.3 percent, a five-month high, according to the Labor Department.

Obama and Romney both tried to turn the jobs report to their advantage. Romney called the unemployment figure “another hammer blow to the struggling middle-class families of America” in an Aug. 3 speech in North Las Vegas, Nevada. Alan Krueger, the chairman of Obama’s Council of Economic Advisers, said Aug. 3 that the report “provides further evidence that the U.S. economy is continuing to recover from the worst downturn since the Great Depression.”

The economy has added private-sector jobs for 29 straight months, he said, a total of 4.5 million positions. He noted in a blog post on the White House website that the unemployment rate rose only because of rounding; the actual change was from 8.217 percent to 8.254 percent.

Blaming Bush
David Axelrod, an Obama campaign strategist, blamed the country’s lingering economic woes on former President George W. Bush’s administration. Axelrod said the U.S. economy lost six million jobs in the six months before Obama took office in January 2009.

“You’d have to go back to the Great Depression to see a crisis like the one we walked into in 2009,” Axelrod said on “Fox News Sunday.”

Axelrod said Romney’s tax plan would increase taxes by an average of $2,000 on middle class families.

“Do we think that raising taxes by $2,000 on the middle class is the way to get the economy moving?” Axelrod said.

A study released by the Brookings Institution in Washington this week said Romney’s plan would shift some burden from those with incomes exceeding $200,000 a year to those earning less.

The Romney campaign has pushed back against the study, saying it doesn’t fully analyze portions of his tax proposal and ignores others. Priebus, the Republican National Committee chairman, said the study doesn’t take into account all of the factors included in Romney’s plan.

“The growth rate that will come out of Mitt Romney’s plan, of reducing taxes on small businesses, reducing taxes on individuals and cutting spending in Washington, that, together, creates growth, will increase individual income rates and jobs and get America moving again,” Priebus said on ABC’s “This Week” when asked about the study.

7 Comments

@KATEHARNER: Normally, I would agree with your statement and thought process. If you don't have something to hide than just show it. However, this is politics - and the tactic is to divert away from other key points and make a big deal. In this case, If he shows the tax returns, he shows himself more of a flip flop on issues - and shows he can be bought with pressure. Not something I want in a President. I am happy that Romney is sticking to his guns.

In addition, even if Romney released the tax returns, another item (or many) would start to come up that would attempt to take center stage like this accusation. The Obama team would also start to quote more of what Romney actually paid in taxes instead of just focusing on the fact that he paid a tax rate of 14% for investment income - this is what I believe they really want. Of course, they don't mention anything about charitable donations etc.

Now, if Reid would like to offer that he trusts his sources so much that if he is incorrect in his accusations, that he steps down and leaves congress... Then I might be willing to see the returns. As for right now, other than a little egg on his face, Reid faces no negatives for making wild accusations like these.

Posted by: Zeo | August 8, 2012 7:18 AM

Report this Comment


I'm sure everyone remembers Donna Douglas, the extremely beautiful and curvaceous "Ellie Mae Clampett" on the Beverly Hillbillies.

In her pre-stardom days, the young Ms. Douglas entered many beauty pageants, and on one occasion found herself the object of the accusations of another contestant's mother.

This irate "pageant mom" insisted that Ms. Douglas was padding her bosom for the swimsuit contest. She screamed at the judges, she screamed at the contestants - no amount of reason could dissuade her from her position.

Donna Douglas turned to the unreasonable woman, and to everyone's amazement, slipped out of her bathing suit. Faced with the stark naked rebuttal to her arguments, the mother turned red-faced and quietly slipped away.

Might I suggest that if Romney truly has nothing to hide, he might put all arguments to rest in 1 minute, al a Donna Douglas.

Of course, if he has been padding something...................

Posted by: KATEHARNER | August 7, 2012 8:46 PM

Report this Comment


This is a diversion and it's worse than accusations. If Mr. Romney had not paid his taxes appropriately in ten years, he would have liens on his property by the IRS and that information would be available to the public. Reid's statements are simply, at best, ridiculous, but at worst are lies. Mr. Reid has not shown us HIS tax returns - only appointees are required to provide such information, not elected senators. How about "you show me yours, and I'll show you mine" Mr. Reid?

I agree with other postings: Get back to work and do the job we hired you to do! Oh yeah, that would have been checking on the appointee Geitner's tax situation, among others.

Posted by: Morraine | August 7, 2012 3:08 PM

Report this Comment


This is not my original thought, but Romney should hold a press conference and agree to release his tax returns as soon as the President releases all his college records.

Posted by: imacpa | August 7, 2012 8:36 AM

Report this Comment


The call that Romney hasn't paid taxes is a diversion tactic, a poor one at that. It relies on the fact that Romney would be required to release his returns to the public to prove them wrong. Then, Reid will fall back on the undisclosed source and say "That person mislead me, it's not my fault I got bad information from someone I believed to be in a good position."

Basically, with the other posters and the rest of America - Reid needs to get and show proof or shut it and focus on the real issues at hand. The hopes of Reid (and lets face it, the democratic party pushing him to say this) rely on the belief that a majority of the American public are easily swayed and believe the unproven up until the point of the election. As to the taxes that Romney pays, he pays his fair share of taxes according to Tax Code taking what deductions and credits he can - a statement he has made. That's what America needs, a business person who looks after all the income *AND* the expenses. If he didn't actually pay his taxes, don't you think we would know this information already, like the many people part of Obamas administrations who haven't?

Posted by: Zeo | August 7, 2012 8:30 AM

Report this Comment


Where's the proof? Do us a favor, Senator Reid. Unless you can back up your accusations, then why don't something useful, like the job the taxpayers compensate you for?

Posted by: nraacct | August 7, 2012 7:37 AM

Report this Comment


I agree that Sen Maj Leader Harry Reid is throwing many accusations against candidate Gov Romney.

Did Mr Reid have the same type of attitude towards Tim Geithner when President Obama appoint him as Secretary of the Treasury?

The 2006 audit of Geithner, and his corrections/amended returns seemed to be a rather large "adjustment"

Posted by: StevenDavis216 | August 6, 2012 2:43 PM

Report this Comment

Add Your Comments...

Already Registered?

If you have already registered to Accounting Today, please use the form below to login. When completed you will immeditely be directed to post a comment.

 

Follow Accounting Today
Advertisement
Advertisement

What's the Biggest Threat or Challenge Facing Accountants?

May 22, 2013

Attendees at Accounting Today's Meet the Editors Dinner at Keens Steakhouse in New York discuss the top issues confronting accountants.

Women in Accounting: Breaking the Mold

May 21, 2013

A continued conversation with Marcum’s Nanette Lee Miller and Janis Cowhey McDonagh about the obstacles women in the accounting profession face when trying to make their way into leadership positions.

Advertisement

SLIDE SHOW

Top 10 Tech Initiatives -- 2013

May 5, 2013

The AICPA's annual list of IT priorities for accounting firms.

Tax Stats: May 2013

April 30, 2013

Our monthly collection of statistics from the world of tax.

10 Biggest Estate Planning Mistakes

April 29, 2013

Help your clients avoid these common pitfalls.

Common E-mail Security Mistakes

April 23, 2013

These five bad habits can make your confidential information -- and that of your clients -- easy to steal.

The Art of the Tax Cartoon

April 9, 2013

A selection of tax cartoons from Philly tax firm Drucker & Scaccetti's 'Finding Humor in Taxes' exhibit.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement