As global companies implicated in a graft scandal in South Africa scramble to contain the damage to their reputations, politicians and law enforcement agencies are prevaricating and stalling official investigations.
The scandal has revolved around members of the wealthy Gupta family, who are friends of President Jacob Zuma and have been accused of looting billions of rand in taxpayer funds and exerting undue influence over the state. Accountants KPMG LLP, public relations firm Bell Pottinger LLP, consultancy McKinsey & Co. and software company SAP SE are among the companies that have been implicated in facilitating, being party to or turning a blind eye to their deals. Zuma and the Guptas deny wrongdoing.
Eight top executives at KPMG’s South African office have quit, Bell Pottinger has collapsed and McKinsey and SAP have suspended or put staff on leave and initiated internal probes. Yet South African authorities haven’t arrested or prosecuted anyone despite the nation’s graft ombudsman and the local media highlighting numerous allegations of wrongdoing.
The scandal’s most telling damage has been to the reputation of the state, the presidency and the ruling African National Congress. Zuma is challenging a directive issued 10 months ago by the ombudsman for the chief justice to establish a judicial commission to probe the allegations and hasn’t followed through on a pledge to set up his own inquiry. While parliament has told four parliamentary committees to conduct probes, only one has scheduled public hearings that are due to begin next week.
Leadership Failure
“While there is an elaborate regulatory framework and constitution in place to keep the state in check, in practice we have seen that circumvented and not responded to,” Jay Kruuse, the director of the Public Service Accountability Monitor at Rhodes University in the southern town of Grahamstown, said by phone. “The checks and balances in the state have been progressively weakened. Investigations drag on and on. It’s a consequence of a failure in leadership across the board.”
Power struggles and a lack of leadership within the investigative agencies may be contributing to the inaction. The police and its elite anti-corruption police unit known as the Hawks both have acting leaders, while the chief prosecutor has been accused by opposition parties and civil-rights groups of being politically aligned to Zuma and his allies.
“I sincerely apologize for what went wrong in KPMG South Africa,” John Veihmeyer, KPMG International’s chairman, said in a statement on Tuesday. “This is not who we are. We will further strengthen the monitoring of which clients we choose to work with and how we handle potentially sensitive client engagements.”
Political Clout
The allegations leveled against the Guptas include offering cabinet posts to officials in exchange for business concessions with Zuma’s consent, using their political clout to get allies appointed to the boards of state companies and diverting state funds meant to be used for a dairy farm to fund a family wedding.
Much of the detail of the family’s dealings emerged from thousands of their emails, which were leaked to the amaBhungane Centre for Investigative Journalism and Scorpio, the Daily Maverick news website’s investigative unit. While the family says the mails are fake, several cabinet ministers and other officials who were mentioned in some of the correspondence confirmed their authenticity.
Zuma is attending the United Nations general assembly in New York and his spokesman Bongani Ngqulunga didn’t answer a call to his mobile phone. Gary Naidoo, a spokesman for the Gupta family, didn’t return a message seeking comment.
Ongoing Investigations
The National Prosecuting Authority says its investigations into the allegations against the Guptas and politicians and other senior officials are ongoing, and denies there have been undue delays in pressing charges.
“My silence does not mean that no work is being done,” chief prosecutor Shaun Abrahams told lawmakers in Cape Town on Sept. 6.
Prosecutions can only be initiated once the police’s special investigative unit, the Hawks, have completed its investigations “and we have heard nothing from them,” Luvuyo Mfaku, a spokesman for the National Prosecuting Authority, said by phone. Hawks spokesman Hangwani Mulaudzi didn’t answer calls to his mobile phone.
The Democratic Alliance, the main opposition party, has led calls for companies that dealt with the Guptas to be investigated and penalized. It filed a complaint against public relations firm Bell Pottinger for fostering racial divisions in South Africa with the main industry group in the U.K., which led to its expulsion and forced it into administration.
The DA has also requested that McKinsey’s domestic and U.S. representatives be called before lawmakers to explain some of the work it did with Trillian, a Gupta-linked company, for state-owned power utility Eskom Holdings SOC Ltd. It also plans to request the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission to investigate the firm’s behavior in South Africa. On Tuesday, the party brought charges of fraud, racketeering and collusion against the consultancy at a Cape Town police station.
No Bribes
“We have not engaged in corruption or paid bribes,” McKinsey said in an emailed response to questions. “Neither the Gupta family nor any company publicly linked to the Guptas has ever been a client of McKinsey. McKinsey never entered into a formal contract with Trillian. McKinsey never paid or authorized payments to Trillian. McKinsey was never asked to approve any payments made by Eskom to Trillian. Eskom paid McKinsey and Trillian separately.”
Like McKinsey and SAP, KPMG ordered an internal inquiry after it was implicated in the leaked emails. The accounting firm’s probe found that the work it did for the Guptas fell “considerably short” of its auditing standards and criticized its role in advising a company controlled by the family on the acquisition of a coal mine from Glencore Plc in a transaction in which Mines Minister Mosebenzi Zwane has been accused of improperly intervening.
It also said four KPMG partners shouldn’t have attended the Gupta family wedding at the gambling resort of Sun City that was alleged to have been funded by taxpayers. KPMG employs 3,400 people in South Africa, according to Business Times newspaper.
Barclays Africa Group Ltd., Investec Ltd. and the nation’s other biggest banks have said they are reviewing their relationship with the audit firm. Sasfin Holdings Ltd., a financial-services company, said on Tuesday it replaced KPMG with Deloitte & Touche LLP as its independent sponsor and was seeking a new auditor.
[SAP Africa spokesperson Anshophie Strydom confirmed an ongoing investigation in an email to Accounting Today. "The Baker McKenzie team of experts are reviewing and scrutinizing large volumes of data, talking to a variety of stakeholders and parties and conducting interviews with all relevant persons," Strydom wrote from Johannesburg. "They are also engaging with and cooperating fully with the appropriate authorities. Whilst we do not yet know when the investigation will be concluded, we have pledged to share the findings of the investigation publicly, once the investigation has been completed." Bell Pottinger declined to comment when contacted by Accounting Today.]
Public and corporate governance go hand-in-hand and slippage will damage South Africa’s ability to attract foreign investment, said Russell Lamberti, a chief strategist at ETM Investment Services in Cape Town.
“If we maintain a corrupt government, it’s not going to be very easy for corporate South Africa to stay clean,” he said. “I don’t see signs of a systemic problem yet, but unless we clean up government then you can see how this starts to suck more people down with it.”
