Chicago elects tax proponent as mayor

Chicago elected Brandon Johnson in the mayoral runoff, a progressive who plans to raise taxes on major corporations to boost the city's revenue, after a divisive race that exposed divisions within Democratic politics.

Johnson, the Cook County commissioner, beat rival Paul Vallas, a former head of Chicago Public Schools who was backed by financial executives and made crime the focus of his campaign, according to the Associated Press.

"Chicago, tonight is just the beginning," Johnson told a crowd of cheering supporters. "With our voices and our votes, we have ushered in a new chapter in the history of our city."

johnson-brandon-chicago-mayor.jpg
Chicago mayoral candidate Brandon Johnson campaigns at Manny's Cafeteria & Delicatessen during the mayoral runoff election at Robert Healy Elementary School in Chicago.
Alex Wroblewski/Getty Images

Johnson, 47, garnered support from the influential Chicago Teachers Union, and surprised many when he made it to the runoff, beating incumbent Lori Lightfoot — the first mayor of Chicago to lose a reelection bid since 1983. He appealed to voters in a largely progressive city and gained momentum by linking his Democrat opponent to the Republican party and to indicted former President Donald Trump.

His victory comes as Chicago faces significant challenges. The city has been slower to recover from the pandemic than New York, Washington and Los Angeles. It's also struggled with crime and high-profile corporate departures, including billionaire Ken Griffin's Citadel and plane maker Boeing Co. 

On Tuesday, Vallas, who received financial support from executives at Citadel and private equity firm Madison Dearborn Partners, said he called Johnson to offer his "full support" on his transition.

"The only pathway forward in our great city is together," Vallas told his supporters, "whether it's quality schools, affordable or equitable economic development, the solutions we adopt and implement must work for all Chicagoans."

Johnson plans a $4 per employee tax on large companies that have at least half of their operation in Chicago. He's also proposing a $1 or $2 tax per securities-trading contract, a plan that would likely need state approval and is fiercely opposed by the city's exchange giants CME Group and Cboe. 

He also wants to increase revenue by raising taxes on hotels, implementing a levy on airlines that pollute the city's air and increasing fees on the sale of high-end properties. He pledged, however, to freeze property taxes, which are largely used to plug the city's pension hole but have been pushing Chicagoans out of the city.

At a campaign event at the City Club of Chicago last week, Johnson touted his ability to bring the city together to solve big issues including crime and pension debt. He also said he planned to bring high-growth businesses to Chicago and added he would need corporations to hire young people as a way to combat crime.

When asked how he reconciled those goals with his plan for corporate taxation, Johnson dodged the question, saying: "What needs to be reconciled? We want a better, stronger, safer Chicago. Everybody wants that. That's how we reconcile: we do what works."

"Businesses want investment, consider me the investor-in-chief," he said.

Crime was a central feature of the campaign and it was Lightfoot's failure to deal with the issue that cost her reelection.

Johnson was also the only candidate who refused to pledge to restaff the police force. Instead, he said it was time to get smart instead of tough, and focused on a plan to train and promote 200 detectives. He also pledged to deal with crime by focusing on mental health.

Chicago is also facing a fiscal cliff next year as federal relief funds come to an end. Ralph Martire, executive director of the Center for Tax and Budget Accountability, a nonpartisan research organization, estimates the next mayor already starts with a revenue gap of at least $373 million. And that doesn't include the annual increase in pension contributions, he said.

Plugging the pension hole will require Johnson to boost property taxes, even if he says he doesn't plan to, Martire said. Otherwise he will have to divert money normally dedicated to services.

"What the property tax levy does for the city of Chicago is cover the vast majority of the pension payment," he said in an interview last week. "It's just not good fiscal policy to suggest that you're not going to rely on enhancing your property tax revenue to cover this."

Bloomberg News
Tax Property taxes Politics and policy
MORE FROM ACCOUNTING TODAY