The New York City Department of Consumer Affairs conducted a two-week-long enforcement sweep of tax preparers across the city and issued violations to one out of every three preparers it inspected, mainly for violating laws governing refund anticipation loans and disclosure of their true qualifications and fees.

Jonathan Mintz
The department conducted close to 850 inspections citywide and issued over 1,000 violations to tax preparers who misrepresented their qualifications, violated consumer rights, or illegally advertised refund anticipation loans as “instant” or “rapid” refunds. Total fines from the enforcement sweep could reach close to $1 million. The agency is encouraging taxpayers to instead take advantage of free or low-cost options for preparing their taxes and claiming the Earned Income Tax Credit.
“There are substantial tax refund dollars waiting for New Yorkers, who have, since 2002, claimed almost $20 billion in Earned Income Tax Credits alone,” said DCA Commissioner Jonathan Mintz in a statement. “That’s why we’re making it as easy as possible for people to file their taxes and claim those refunds. And since the IRS issues these refunds in such a short amount of time, there’s no reason for such expensive, often deceptively sold loans getting in between you and every dollar of your refund.”
His department inspected income tax preparers charged with previous violations in 2011 and 2010, along with other preparers who are located in neighborhoods with large populations of immigrants and high usage of refund anticipation loans.
The DCA found that 65 percent of businesses that received a violation last year and were inspected this year, were complying with the law. In New York City, tax preparers must post their qualifications, fees and charges, and whether or not they will represent consumers at a government audit. Tax preparers must sign every tax return, and provide their customers with a copy of their tax return and a receipt for their services.
New Yorkers with children who earn less than $50,000 or $18,000 for those who do not have children can visit one of 69 Volunteer Income Tax Assistance sites in the five boroughs where a certified volunteer will prepare their taxes for free, the agency noted. New Yorkers earning less than $57,000 can also file their taxes online for free at nyc.gov/taxprep. The city is also partnering with Intuit and One Economy Corporation to offer access to free online tax preparation software. New Yorkers can also have their tax returns prepared at a participating H&R Block office with a new city-sponsored coupon for $29. To qualify for the H&R Block discount, residents must earn less than $41,000 with children or $31,000 if they have no children.












5 Comments
As an addendum to the previous comment, the DCA spokesperson called me back to say that Republic Bank is still providing RALs, but this will be the last tax season it will be doing that under the orders of the FDIC. For an update on the state of the RAL industry, check out our story, "Consumer Groups Foresee End of RALs This Year" at http://www.accountingtoday.com/news/Consumer-Groups-Foresee-End-Tax-RALs-This-Year-61556-1.html
Posted by: MikeCohn | March 1, 2012 5:32 PM
Report this Comment
Gary Z and JoanM, a spokesperson for the Department of Consumer Affairs told me that CPAs and enrolled agents were among those who received violations.
JDavis, the DCA said in its announcement that the refund anticipation loans are not illegal in New York City, but tax preparers must disclose that the products are loans with annualized interest rates as high as 500 percent, significantly reducing an expected refund.
While RALs are not illegal, many of the tax prep chains are phasing them out because of the IRS's elimination of the debt indicator. Also, some of the banks that had been providing the RALs like SBBT, HSBC and Republic have been pressured by regulators to get out of the businesses.
Posted by: MikeCohn | March 1, 2012 11:45 AM
Report this Comment
Is it me or is this article false. There are no more refund anticipated loan !!!!! We should bring them back as the IRS can seem to get there act together with its computer system and communicating that it has big problems..
Repeat there are no more Refund anticipation loans ...
Posted by: JDAVIS | March 1, 2012 10:32 AM
Report this Comment
Were any of the Tax Preparers Enrolled Agents?
Posted by: JoanM | March 1, 2012 10:01 AM
Report this Comment
Were any of the tax preparers who were cited CPAs?
Posted by: Gary Z | March 1, 2012 7:54 AM
Report this Comment
Add Your Comments...
Already Registered?
If you have already registered to Accounting Today, please use the form below to login. When completed you will immeditely be directed to post a comment.
Not Registered?
You must be registered to post a comment.