Free Site Registration


UBS Whistleblower Secures $104 Million IRS Award

Print
Email
Reprints
Washington, D.C. (September 11, 2012)

By Tom Schoenberg and David Voreacos

Bloomberg

(Bloomberg) Bradley Birkenfeld, the former UBS AG banker who told the Internal Revenue Service how the bank helped thousands of Americans evade taxes, secured an IRS award of $104 million, an amount his lawyers said may be the largest ever for an individual U.S. whistleblower.

Birkenfeld told authorities how UBS bankers came to the U.S. to woo rich Americans, managed $20 billion of their assets, and helped them cheat the IRS. He pleaded guilty to conspiracy in 2008, a year after reporting the bank’s conduct to the Justice Department, U.S. Senate, IRS and Securities and Exchange Commission. He was released from prison Aug. 1.

The award is the first issued under the IRS tax whistle- blower law, according to his attorneys, Stephen M. Kohn and Dean A. Zerbe, of the Washington-based National Whistleblowers Center.

“The IRS sent 104 million messages to whistle-blowers around the world—that there is now a safe and secure way to report tax fraud,” the lawyers said in a statement.

UBS avoided prosecution in the U.S. by agreeing to pay $780 million, disclosing data on more than 250 Swiss accounts, and admitting it helped foster tax evasion. It later agreed to hand over data on another 4,450 accounts. Since Birkenfeld came forward, at least 33,000 Americans have voluntarily disclosed offshore accounts to the IRS, generating more than $5 billion.

“Today the IRS sent a message to every American taxpayer who still has an illegal offshore account,” Kohn said. “Turn yourself in while there is still an amnesty program. Turn yourself in before your banker does.”

Swiss Bank
Birkenfeld, 47, worked at Zurich-based UBS, the largest Swiss bank, for five years. He sought a reward from the IRS of as much as 30 percent of any taxes the agency recovered as a result of his whistle-blowing activities.

He began serving a 40-month sentence in January 2010 at Schuylkill Federal Correctional Institution in Minersville, Pa. He received good-time credit that reduced his term, according to his lawyers. He is now in home confinement, and seeking a presidential pardon, Kohn said.

The IRS said in a statement Tuesday that “the whistleblower statute provides a valuable tool to combat tax noncompliance, and this award reflects our commitment to the law.”

The Government Accountability Office found last year that the program moved too slowly.

Tipster Incentives
The IRS whistleblower program—created by Congress in 2006 to boost tax revenue by giving incentives to tipsters—had become the place where allegations of tax were left unaddressed, critics said. Over the past five years, more than 1,300 claims were filed against almost 10,000 companies and individuals, alleging tax underpayments of at least $2 million apiece.

Just three awards had been paid through June 19. The IRS won’t disclose the total dollar amount. Taxpayers annually owe $385 billion more than the IRS is able to collect, the agency said.
In contrast, the U.S. Treasury has recovered more than $21 billion since 1986 due to whistleblower tips under a similar law that covers other federal agencies.

The IRS is “demoralizing whistle-blowers,” Senator Charles Grassley, who sponsored the whistleblower law, wrote to Treasury Secretary Timothy F. Geithner in April.

‘Timely Manner’
“The IRS does not have a problem attracting whistle blowers. The IRS’s current problem is processing and compensating whistle-blowers in a timely manner,” said Grassley, an Iowa Republican. As a result, “I am now concerned that whistleblowers will stop coming forward.”

Whistleblower claims “can take years to go through the IRS review and award determination process,” and the IRS doesn’t collect enough information on why claims are rejected, the Government Accountability Office said in a report last year.

The program hasn’t met expectations, IRS officials said in interviews earlier this year. “It’s fair to say the whistleblower program isn’t where we would like it yet,” said Steven T. Miller, IRS deputy commissioner for services and enforcement, who oversees the whistleblower office. “And I think it’s fair to say we are working hard on it.”

The IRS doesn’t talk to whistleblowers more frequently because of concerns about violating strict laws protecting taxpayer privacy, Miller said. He attributed the slow pace to taxpayers appealing IRS rulings. The agency says prospective whistleblowers should expect to wait as long as seven years for an award.

5 Comments

What happened to "clean hands"?

This is just not appropriate.

The inmates are running the asylum- is there any hope naywhere?

Posted by: Tickslash | September 13, 2012 6:25 AM

Report this Comment


What a system, what a joke!

Posted by: YooperUSA | September 12, 2012 2:06 PM

Report this Comment


So, I guess the prison sentence was worth it then. Not a bad return on your LCUs (Life Credit Units) invested in some short term U.S. incarceration. However, Americans abroad now live with the over-the-top extra territorial response by the IRS with its various forms of 'Bait and Switch' Voluntary Disclosure programs, disproportionate penalties on non U.S resident and new immigrant Minnows, and the Congressional pile on with FATCA effecting EVERY country in the Universe. You have to wonder if we would be dealing with all this FATCA fallout, if Bradley hadn't walked in the front door and handed the IRS and Justice Department the information that they had failed to obtain from their own investigative work. The UNINTENDED consequences of the chain of events he started leads up to a very uncertain FATCA future, which unfortunately gets little or no reporting in the U.S. media. Is this type of result really good for America? So now Bradley gets $104 M, and I get more tax complexity, as I fill out duplicate FBAR and FATCA forms as required under serious penalty threat! Then there are the many Canadian/U.S dual citizens who now line up at Consulates to renounce their citizenship to get out from the IRS "offshore jihad". Let's not over look the FATCA Compliance Complex (FCC) that is born to make BIG money off this latest World Wide regulation, and now are invested in its continued rollout and success. We only read about it on specialized tax and Accounting blogs, but not in the MSM. Who would have thought that Bradley's whistle blowing would lead to this? So it goes. It all started because of a simple desire by Congress and the IRS to stop U.S. "Residents" living in the Homeland from evading taxes offshore, but they created a MONSTER instead. Because of the unique nature of U.S. Citizenship taxation, many Americans abroad now ponder their fate.

They are being shut out of banking in the counties of their residence or they are forced to join an onerous "voluntary" program with all its unknown complications and penalties before their data is handed over to the IRS by foreign financial institutions.

Congress doesn't even know what they voted for, and what the FATCANATICs in Treasury have created as a result. The world doesn't need another complicated, expensive ~388 page regulation to heap complexity onto an already struggling economy and weak financial industry. Surely there was another way to deal with homeland tax evasion without world wide bounties and FATCA. It will be many years before Journalist begin to wonder "how was we ended up with a global GATCA and its paralyzing economic and systemic impacts?" Although the OECD has long been on a mission to end tax competition between nations, and FATCA certainly is much applauded and supported by them as the stepping stone towards their total asset transparency dream world, I think the real story telling can start right here with Bradley as the catalyst that made it happen.

Posted by: Just Me | September 12, 2012 11:10 AM

Report this Comment


I agree with nintrey.

Posted by: Mark K | September 12, 2012 10:45 AM

Report this Comment


It seems to me our system is broken. A man can break our law and then be rewarded 100 million dollars, tax dollars that is, after he clearly was partly to blame.

He served his time and got out early. That should have been sufficient of a reward.

Posted by: nintrey | September 12, 2012 10:12 AM

Report this Comment

Add Your Comments...

Already Registered?

If you have already registered to Accounting Today, please use the form below to login. When completed you will immeditely be directed to post a comment.

 

Follow Accounting Today
Advertisement
Advertisement

Women in Accounting: Where are the Leading Ladies?

May 17, 2013

Marcum’s Nanette Lee Miller and Janis Cowhey McDonagh sat down with managing editor Tamika Cody to discuss some of the obstacles women in the accounting profession face when trying to make their way into leadership positions.

IMA’s Jeff Thomson on the Role and Skills of Management Accountants

May 8, 2013

Institute of Management Accountants president and CEO Jeffrey Thomson discusses why accounting students should consider management accounting as a career, and the IMA's partnership with John Wiley & Sons.

Breaking out of Molds to Get Ahead

May 6, 2013

ConvergenceCoaching partner Jennifer Wilson talks with Accounting Today senior editor Danielle Lee about how female accountants can position themselves better for a promotion at their firms.

Advertisement

SLIDE SHOW

Top 10 Tech Initiatives -- 2013

May 5, 2013

The AICPA's annual list of IT priorities for accounting firms.

Tax Stats: May 2013

April 30, 2013

Our monthly collection of statistics from the world of tax.

10 Biggest Estate Planning Mistakes

April 29, 2013

Help your clients avoid these common pitfalls.

Common E-mail Security Mistakes

April 23, 2013

These five bad habits can make your confidential information -- and that of your clients -- easy to steal.

The Art of the Tax Cartoon

April 9, 2013

A selection of tax cartoons from Philly tax firm Drucker & Scaccetti's 'Finding Humor in Taxes' exhibit.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement